Your cart (0)
Skip to content

Fire Pit Vs Fire Ring: What’s Better For Your Backyard?

When it comes to outdoor heating and hardscaping ambiance, fire pits and fire rings are two of the most popular options. Both bring the inherent appeal of a crackling fire into your backyard or outdoor living space, but which one is the best choice for you?  This post will compare fire pits and fire rings across multiple factors, from safety and price to design variety...

fire pit vs fire ring

When it comes to outdoor heating and hardscaping ambiance, fire pits and fire rings are two of the most popular options. Both bring the inherent appeal of a crackling fire into your backyard or outdoor living space, but which one is the best choice for you? 

This post will compare fire pits and fire rings across multiple factors, from safety and price to design variety and ease of use. We'll even get into details like maintenance and regulations so that you can make the most informed decision.

Whether you're new to outdoor fires or looking to switch things up, read on to find out which option might fit your needs best.

What’s A Fire Pit?

A fire pit is a contained fire structure that can come in various shapes, sizes, and materials. From classic wood-burning designs to modern propane-fueled models, fire pits have evolved to fit just about any aesthetic and functionality requirements. They can be permanent fixtures in your backyard or portable units you can take on camping trips.

Pros:

  • Versatility: Fire pits come in multiple fuel types, such as wood, propane, gel and natural gas, each with unique benefits.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: With a wide range of designs, from rustic to modern, a fire pit can be a centerpiece in your outdoor space.
  • Heat Output: High-quality fire pits can produce significant heat, ideal for chilly evenings.
  • Cooking Options: Many fire pits can accommodate grilling grates or rotisseries, offering cooking possibilities.

Cons:

  • Initial Cost: Quality fire pits can be expensive, especially propane and natural gas models.
  • Maintenance Needs: Unlike fire rings, fire pits may require more frequent cleaning and upkeep, depending on the fuel type.
  • Fuel Costs: Propane and natural gas fire pits can accumulate higher running costs over time.
  • Permit Requirements: Permanent installations often require building permits and must adhere to local fire codes, typically being installed by professionals. 

What’s A Fire Ring?

A fire ring is a simple, usually circular metal ring that contains a fire. Primarily used for wood-burning fires, they are often found in campgrounds and can be portable or permanent. Fire rings are typically more basic in design compared to fire pits, focusing more on function than aesthetics.

Pros:

  • Affordability: Fire rings are generally less expensive than fire pits, making them a budget-friendly option.
  • Low Maintenance: Being simpler in design, they require less upkeep, especially when used for wood-burning.
  • Portability: Many fire rings are lightweight and easily disassembled, making them great for camping trips.
  • Easy to Use: Fire rings are straightforward to use, often requiring just firewood and a match to get started.

Cons:

  • Limited Functionality: They usually serve a single purpose, containing a wood fire, and offering fewer features than fire pits.
  • Aesthetic Limitations: Fire rings are generally not as attractive as fire pits and offer limited design options.
  • Lower Heat Output: Due to their open design, fire rings may not provide as much heat as enclosed fire pits.
  • Safety Concerns: The open structure can make fire control more challenging, posing potential safety risks.

Safety Comparison

Fire pits typically offer a more controlled environment for burning, thanks to their enclosed structures, which may include mesh covers or glass barriers. This setup reduces the risk of stray embers escaping and starting a fire. On the other hand, fire rings are more open, making it easier for embers to fly out. That said, propane fire pits with safety features like emergency shut-off valves set the gold standard for fire safety.

Summary: Generally speaking, fire pits are often considered safer than fire rings due to their enclosed design, though variations like propane pits can be even safer.

Price Comparison

Fire pits come in a wide range of prices, from affordable basic models to high-end pieces that can cost thousands of dollars. The type of fuel a fire pit requires, like wood, propane, or natural gas can also influence the cost. Fire rings, in contrast, are generally less expensive, making them a popular choice for those looking to save money. However, it's important to consider the ongoing costs of fuel and maintenance, which can add up for both options but are typically higher for fire pits.

Summary: Fire pits generally cost more upfront, particularly for gas-powered models, but fire rings can be the more economical choice for those on a budget.

Longevity Comparison

Fire rings, usually made of lighter metals, are more susceptible to rust and wear. However, with regular maintenance, including cleaning and protective coatings, the life of a fire ring can be extended significantly. Fire pits, though, especially those made from high-quality materials like stainless steel or cast iron, tend to have a longer lifespan. They are designed to withstand the elements and high temperatures. 

Summary: Fire pits often last longer due to sturdier construction and materials, but the longevity of fire rings can be extended with proper maintenance.

Design Variety

Fire pits come in various shapes, sizes, and styles, from more traditional rustic stone structures to sleek and contemporary modern designs fueled by propane or natural gas. The range of choices allows you to find a fire pit that complements your outdoor decor. Fire rings, on the other hand, tend to be more basic in design and general appearance, usually circular and made of metal. While custom designs are available, they are less common and typically focus more on functionality than aesthetics.

Summary: Fire rings are generally more utilitarian in appearance, while fire pits offer a broader range of design options, catering to various aesthetic tastes.

Maintenance

Fire rings are simpler by design, usually consisting of just the ring itself, making them easier to clean and maintain. However, their metal construction may require occasional rust treatment and repainting. Fire pits often have more components that require regular cleaning and maintenance, such as gas lines in propane models or ash pans in wood-burning units. Ignition systems can also fail and require repair or replacement.

Summary: Fire pits generally require more maintenance, especially gas-powered ones, while fire rings tend to be easier to clean and upkeep.

Ease of Use

Fire pits, especially gas-powered models, may require a bit more know-how for safe and efficient operation, such as understanding venting requirements and adjusting flame height. Fire rings are often as simple as placing firewood in the ring and lighting it. There's not much that can go wrong, making them a good choice for camping trips or for those who prefer a no-fuss option.

Summary: Fire rings are typically easier to use due to their straightforward design, while fire pits may require more setup and operational knowledge.

Installation

Fire pits can range from simple DIY kits to intricate custom installations that require professional help. Permanent fire pits often need foundational work, like digging and laying a stone base, and may even require gas line installations for propane or natural gas models. This complexity usually means higher installation costs and possibly needing permits.

Fire rings, being simpler, are generally easier to install. Portable models need no installation at all, and even permanent ones usually just require a relatively level area and maybe some gravel for drainage. They are often the quicker and more straightforward choice for those looking to get a safe fire started with minimal hassle.

Regulations and Limitations

Fire pits often come with a host of local regulations, such as building codes and fire safety rules, particularly if they're permanent structures. Gas-powered models may also require installation by licensed gas line plumbers, and periodic inspections to ensure they're up to code. Failure to comply can result in fines or the removal of the fire pit.

Fire rings, especially portable ones, usually face fewer restrictions. However, it's essential to check local open-burning laws, as fire rings used for wood-burning may still require a permit. Always make sure to consult local ordinances and community guidelines before installing either a fire pit or fire ring to avoid legal complications.

Environmental Impact

Both fire pits and fire rings contribute to air pollution through the release of smoke and particulates. Wood-burning models, in particular, can release harmful compounds. Gas-powered fire pits produce fewer emissions but rely on fossil fuels. Fire rings, due to their open design, may release more pollutants into the air. It's crucial to consider environmental factors and opt for eco-friendly choices like clean-burning fuels when possible.

Other Articles You May Like