Your cart (0)
Skip to content

Gas Fire Pit Vs Wood Fire Pit: Let’s Choose!

Choosing between a gas and wood fire pit can be a tough decision, each offering its own set of benefits and drawbacks. This comprehensive guide aims to break down the critical factors to consider, helping you make the best choice for your outdoor space. Gas or Wood Fire Pit: What Are the Main Differences? The fundamental difference between gas and wood fire pits lies in...

gas fire pit vs wood fire pit

Choosing between a gas and wood fire pit can be a tough decision, each offering its own set of benefits and drawbacks. This comprehensive guide aims to break down the critical factors to consider, helping you make the best choice for your outdoor space.

Gas or Wood Fire Pit: What Are the Main Differences?

The fundamental difference between gas and wood fire pits lies in the fuel source: one uses gas, either natural or propane, while the other relies on wood logs or pellets. This choice impacts various factors, such as installation complexity, cost, and maintenance. 

Gas fire pits are generally easier to use and maintain but can be more expensive upfront. Wood fire pits offer a traditional, rustic experience but require regular cleaning and have variable costs related to wood supply.

Gas Fire Pit Overview

A gas fire pit offers a clean and convenient way to enjoy a controlled fire in your outdoor space.

Pros:

  • Ease of Use: Gas fire pits are incredibly user-friendly. With the turn of a knob or push of a button, you can have an instant fire without the need for kindling or fire starters.
  • Clean Burning: They produce less soot and ash, making them environmentally friendlier and easier to maintain.
  • Control: You have better control over the flame size and heat output, which can be essential for cooking or achieving a particular ambiance.
  • Safety: Generally considered safer than wood fire pits, as they don’t produce flying sparks or embers that could cause accidental fires.

Cons:

  • Cost: Gas fire pits are generally more expensive to purchase and install, especially if you need a gas line extension.
  • Fuel Availability: You’ll need a consistent source of propane or natural gas, which can also incur ongoing costs.
  • Permits and Regulations: Gas fire pits often require permits and must meet specific local codes, which can make the installation process more complicated.

H3 - Wood Fire Pit Overview

A wood fire pit offers a traditional, rustic experience complete with the crackle and aroma of burning wood.

Pros:

  • Sensory Experience: The sights, sounds, and smells of a wood fire are incomparable and create a traditional, cozy atmosphere.
  • Low Initial Cost: Wood fire pits are usually cheaper to buy and easier to install than gas alternatives.
  • Fuel Flexibility: You can use a variety of wood types, giving you more control over the cost and the type of fire you want to create.
  • No Ongoing Fuel Costs: If you have access to free or cheap wood, running costs can be minimal.

Cons:

  • Maintenance: Wood fire pits require regular cleaning to remove ash and soot.
  • Safety Concerns: The open flames and flying sparks pose a higher risk of accidental fires.
  • Less Control: It's more challenging to control the flame and heat, particularly in windy conditions.

How to Choose: Checklist

To help you decide between a gas and wood fire pit, ask yourself the following questions:

  1. What's your budget? Gas fire pits are generally more expensive upfront, but wood fire pits may have higher ongoing fuel costs.
  2. How much maintenance are you willing to do? Gas fire pits require less maintenance, while wood fire pits need regular cleaning.
  3. What kind of experience do you want? If you love the authentic crackle and smell of wood, a wood fire pit may be for you.
  4. Do you have any environmental concerns? Gas fire pits are generally cleaner-burning than wood fire pits.
  5. What are the local regulations? Be sure to check your local ordinances for both gas and wood fire pits, as permits or restrictions may apply.

Cost

Gas fire pits typically have a higher initial cost because of the complexity of their design and the materials used. If you don't already have a gas line in your outdoor space, installing one can be expensive. Wood fire pits, on the other hand, are generally cheaper to purchase and can even be DIY projects if you are so inclined.

It's essential to consider ongoing fuel costs. For a gas fire pit, this means a continuous supply of natural gas or propane. Wood fire pits may seem cheaper but consider the cost of buying firewood or the time to collect and prepare it.

While wood fire pits usually have a lower upfront cost, gas fire pits can be more economical in the long run depending on fuel costs.

Safety

Gas fire pits generally offer better safety features, including controlled flame height and emergency shut-off valves. Wood fire pits, however, produce flying sparks and embers that pose a higher fire risk, requiring additional safety measures like spark guards.

Installation

Installing a gas fire pit usually involves more steps, potentially requiring a gas line extension and permits. Wood fire pits are typically easier to set up but may require a suitable base or fireproof mat to ensure safety and compliance with local regulations.

Fuel Availability

Gas fire pits require a consistent supply of propane or natural gas, which might not be readily available in all locations. Wood fire pits offer more flexibility, as you can use different types of wood, but availability and cost can vary by region.

Convenience

Gas fire pits are generally more convenient, offering instant ignition and flame control. Wood fire pits require effort to start and maintain, including gathering wood, using fire starters, and regular cleaning.

Wood fire pits are usually more portable due to their simpler design, making them easier to move. Gas fire pits are often heavier and may be connected to a gas line, limiting mobility.

For ease of use and control, gas fire pits are generally more convenient. However, wood fire pits offer greater portability.

Maintenance

Gas fire pits require professional maintenance for tasks like checking gas lines or installing new parts, making them somewhat complicated to repair. Wood fire pits are generally simpler to maintain but require more frequent cleaning and potential replacement of parts like grates or spark guards.


While gas fire pits require specialized maintenance less frequently, wood fire pits demand regular cleaning and may have more wear and tear.

Aesthetics

Gas fire pits often offer a more modern, sleek design and come with a variety of aesthetic accessories like glass beads or artificial logs. Wood fire pits provide a rustic, traditional look and can be accented with natural stones or custom grates.


Gas fire pits offer a contemporary, customizable appearance, while wood fire pits deliver a timeless, rustic aesthetic.

Efficiency

Gas fire pits are generally more energy-efficient, converting most of the fuel to heat. Wood fire pits are less efficient, with much of the wood's energy going to waste as smoke and ash.

For better fuel and energy efficiency, gas fire pits are the superior choice, although wood fire pits offer more robust natural lighting.

Environmental Impact

Gas fire pits produce fewer emissions and are cleaner-burning, making them a more environmentally friendly option. Wood fire pits generate more smoke and particulates, contributing to air pollution and potentially deforestation if wood is not sourced sustainably.

Regulations and Restrictions

Local ordinances may restrict the use of wood fire pits due to air quality concerns or fire hazards. Gas fire pits are generally more accepted but may require permits or professional installation, depending on local laws.

Wood Fire Pit vs Gas Fire Pit: Final Verdict

If convenience and regulatory concerns are high priorities for you, a gas fire pit is likely the better choice, particularly for urban or denser suburban settings. On the other hand, if you value a more authentic, sensory experience and have a ready supply of wood, a wood fire pit could be more suitable.

Other Articles You May Like